Published Updated on 9 minutes of reading FAQ Kitchen runs on reader-support. We may earn a small affiliate commission on products purchased via links on our site.
Seasonal | Christmas | Leftovers
Whether you’re an eggnog lover or coquito fan there’s one thing the two have in common – there’s usually quite a bit leftover! In this post, we’ve compiled a list of some incredibly delicious “out of the box” eggnog recipes that use up leftover eggnog and coquito, both of which can be swapped out of the recipes for the other! So, if you have a big punch bowl sitting in your fridge and don’t want to waste it, follow the links below to try one of these eggnog recipes and experience this holiday beverage in a new way.
It’s that time of year again, whether you are a fan of eggnog, coquito, horchata or rompope this list of leftover recipes is the perfect way to use up and repurpose these holiday beverages into something new! Any of these drinks can be switched out for the other as they are all very similar in flavor profile and work well within the recipes below. So, don’t stress when you see a recipe that features leftover eggnog if you’re looking to use up your coquito or horchata or vice versa you can just sub out the eggnog and you’ll be good to go!
Everyone hates throwing out leftovers! It’s such a waste, while we usually go out of our way to find recipes that let us use up leftover stuffing and turkey from our big holiday feasts, eggnog usually gets dumped and forgotten. Let’s just admit it, even though we all love our holiday drinks like eggnog, coquito, and horchata at some point … enough is enough… you can only drink so much of it before it becomes a nose turner.
At first, it may seem like there really isn’t anything you can do with a holiday drink beyond, well drinking it. We are happy to report that there are recipes that reuse and repurpose our most beloved holiday eggnog. In this post, you will find a list of recipes that use eggnog and coquito leftovers in a variety of ways to experience the flavor in differentpresentations, including cupcakes, cookies, pudding, cakes, ice cream, and some others that you will love and will surprise everyone with.
What do you do with too much eggnog?
There are numerous recipes where you can use leftover eggnog and discover new flavors by experimenting with different recipes, but some of the ideas you can make include cookies, cakes, puddings, and different co*cktails.
Is it OK to freeze eggnog?
If you bought a carton of eggnog at the store, it’s best to freeze the eggnog before opening it and before the expiration date on the carton. It will keep in the freezer for six months. If you made homemade eggnog or you have an open store-bought container you can still freeze it, but the shelf-life moves down to around 3 months because it has been exposed to air and possible contaminants.
How long will eggnog keep in the refrigerator?
If refrigerated, store-bought eggnog lasts 5-7 days after opening. Canned eggnog has a shelf life of 4 to 5 months and should be consumed within 5-7 days of opening. Homemade eggnog is only going to last 4 maybe 5 days tops in the fridge. If you are going to freeze it don’t let it go past day 3.
Can you reheat Leftover eggnog?
Yes, you can reheat eggnog, while can be served hot or cold reheating it will kill off any bacteria that may be present. To reheat the eggnog use a saucepan and medium heat, stir constantly until steaming, and then remove from heat.
Why is eggnog only sold during Christmas?
No one buys it! Remember when we mentioned that enough is enough when it comes to eggnog, well, pretty much everyone feels that way. While people seem to enjoy it around the holidays they aren’t in a hurry for it to come back right away so the 10-11 month break is just perfect!
What’s the difference between coquito and eggnog?
The milk! Coquito uses coconut milk, traditionally and eggnog goes full dairy with the use of real eggs! For those of you that aren’t familiar with Coquito, it’s a Puerto Rican drink that is just as delicious (some even argue more so) than eggnog and hits all the same flavor notes.
What’s The Difference Between Horchata And Eggnog?
Again, the milk and usually the alcohol. Horchata is a lot thinner than eggnog and typically uses rice milk or almond and it doesn’t have eggs, which makes it very vegan-friendly! It’s not usually spiked either. It still has those warm spice flavors and really tastes great and making it a good eggnog alternative.
27 Recipes That Put Leftover Eggnog to Good Use!
Coquito Bread Pudding (Budín de Coquito) w/ Coquito Toffee
Coquito Bread Pudding (Budn de Coquito) is a comforting dessert recipe that combines the popular coconut and rum co*cktail. It can be made with or without alcoholic coquito.
Eggnog Bread With Quick + Easy Eggnog Glaze
Celebrate the holidays in style with this delectable and moist eggnog bread recipe. It has all of the best Christmas flavors in a tasty loaf. If you don’t know what to do with the leftover eggnog, this is the recipe for you.
Eggnog Latte
On the holidays, eggnog is typically a cold-weather beverage. Learn how to make this simple homemade latte recipe to keep you warm during the holiday season’s chilly days and nights!
Coquito Tres Leches (Coconut and Rum Tres Leches Cake)
Serve a Coquito Tres Leches: an airy sponge cake soaked in Puerto Rican coconut and rum nog to make the holidays brighter and merrier.
Pumpkin Eggnog French Toast
Eggnog with Pumpkin Spiced pumpkin bread dipped in eggnog batter and served with sugared cranberries. With leftover eggnog, this is the ideal holiday breakfast.
Chocolate Eggnog Cookies
This is a great way to use up leftover eggnog! These Chocolate Eggnog Cookies combine creamy holiday eggnog with the rich sweetness of chocolate in one pillowy soft bite!
5 Minute Creamy Eggnog Ice Cream
Even on cold days, we crave ice cream, and with this perfect combination of leftover eggnog and 6 other ingredients, you can make eggnog ice cream in 5 minutes with no fuss, no-cook, and no-churn! This creamy eggnog ice cream recipe is the ideal cold-weather treat!
Rich and Creamy Eggnog Whipped Cream
This is a recipe that uses leftover eggnog to add a festive touch to all of your holiday desserts and drinks with a sweet scoop of rich and luscious eggnog whipped cream.
Frosted Eggnog Cookies
Frosted eggnog cookies are made with egg yolks, rum extract, and nutmeg to taste exactly like the holiday drink. You can also use whatever leftover eggnog you have! This Christmas, try the festive recipe.
Eggnog Cupcakes with Bourbon
You’re stuck with what’s left of the eggnog. Then these Eggnog cupcakes are for you; they’re spiked with bourbon and dusted with nutmeg.
Coquito (Coconut Rum) Cheesecake
Are you a Coquito fan? This is Puerto Rico’s favorite holiday beverage. Coquito co*cktails transform into a creamy cheesecake and then top it off! Try it today and enjoy a unique flavor.
Eggnog Cake with Eggnog Cream Cheese Frosting
The flavors of the holiday are baked right into a flaky, soft cake in this eggnog cake with creamy eggnog cream cheese frosting! It is unpretentious and ideal for making with children.
Coquito Cookies with Coquito Buttercream Frosting
This recipe will quickly become a family favorite. Coquito cookies with coquito buttercream frosting contain coquito in both the batter and the frosting. It’s a seasonal sweet treat.
Eggnog Cheesecake Bars
Creamy Eggnog Cheesecake Bars are a delicious addition to your holiday baking. Made with a graham cracker crust and eggnog cream cheese filling from a previous recipe!
No Bake Mini Eggnog Trifle
With layers of chocolate cake, eggnog toffee mousse, and whipped cream, this Easy No Bake Mini Eggnog Trifle is a light tasting dessert. If you have leftover eggnog, this is the recipe for you to try today!
Eggnog Fudge Recipe
If you enjoy the flavor of eggnog, you’ll love this delicious eggnog fudge recipe. This sweet and creamy holiday fudge is ideal for homemade gifts, a holiday dessert tray, or a special treat for your family. This fudge recipe is fantastic.
Eggnog Coffee Cake
This recipe is the best use for leftover eggnog you can think of. Try this easy Christmas breakfast or brunch recipe for Eggnog Coffee Cake. A cinnamon nutmeg walnut streusel tops an eggnog cake.
Perfectly Moist Eggnog Cupcakes
These perfectly delicious Eggnog Cupcakes with Eggnog Buttercream Icing are the ideal treat when you’re craving something sweet and have some leftover eggnog from a previous celebration. This will quickly become a favorite in your household! Cupcakes with eggnog filling and buttercream icing
Perfectly Perfect Eggnog Waffles
Can you imagine the mix of flavor when using leftover eggnog and preparing delicious waffles? Perfectly delightful, this Eggnog waffle recipe is a holiday season staple. It’s the ideal snack for breakfast, dinner, or even dessert. Try them today and enjoy this unique taste!
The Best Eggnog Pancakes
Have you ever considered making the best leftover eggnog pancakes? Yes, with leftovers from your previous gatherings. This perfect eggnog pancake recipe can be made with homemade or store-bought eggnog. With these, you can’t go wrong. Eggnog Pancakes arethe ideal Christmas morning meal.
Eggnog Latte
How to Make an Eggnog Latte from eggnog leftovers. Follow the link to get the full recipe and enjoy this Eggnog Latte on a cold night at home.
Pumpkin Eggnog
This easy bourbon Pumpkin Eggnog is an autumn twist on the classic winter co*cktail and takes about 10 minutes from start to finish.
Eggnog Bundt Cake
Eggnog Bundt Cake is a delicious cake with the flavors of Christmas. The eggnog and nutmeg remind us so much of Christmas.
The Best Chocolate Eggnog Cupcakes Recipe
Follow the link to get the full recipe for these Eggnog chocolate cupcakes, which make good use of leftover eggnog and have a delicious taste when these ingredients are combined.
Boozy Eggnog co*cktail
A different way to drink eggnog can be found at the link below. Try this Boozy Eggnog co*cktail, made with store-bought eggnog, brandy, amaretto, and freshly grated nutmeg.
Eggnog Bread and Butter Pudding
This simple Christmas dessert will impress your family and guests with fresh cranberries and eggnog leftovers in this easy bread and butter pudding recipe. Try it today and you’ll astound everyone.
Egg Liqueur Parfait
If you have leftover eggnog and don’t know how to use it with this quick, easy, and gluten-free egg liqueur dessert recipe you will enjoy a unique taste that will impress everyone at home.
Have a cooking question?
Get it answered on FAQ Kitchen
Ask Here
